After reading through the reviews, I figured I would add my own.
For comparative reference:
I have been playing disc golf for around 7-8 years and I'm mediocre at best =)
Putting style is a combination of spin/push
On to the good stuff. Over the past few years, I have mainly putted with something like a Wizard or Pa 3 and then switched to a beadless Aviar and found a lot of success due to the drop in stability and lack of bead. I'm not necessarily a hard/fast putter, but I'm not floating them in there either. I putt somewhere in between.
I've been using the Warden for about a year now and can confidently say I have found my putter of choice. Just like a beadless Aviar, I love the fact that there is no bead on this disc and it just feels really comfortable in my hand. I also really like the plastic of this disc. I rotate between both the classic, stiffer plastic and the classic soft. Both plastics have great tackiness to them and I get considerably better grip on the disc than I did with a DX beadless Aviar, especially in wet conditions. I like having both plastic options because I play my disc golf in Michigan. Summer usually calls for a harder putter for me, and likewise, colder conditions in the Fall/Winter/Spring usually means I need something softer for grip.
What I like the most about this disc is the glide. I find that I can put less effort on my putts and never worry about them not getting to the basket. The Warden allows me to run jump putts from out to about 80-90ft and gives me an honest chance at making them. Every other putter I've ever used would either dump out to the left on me or my spin on a jump putt would turn the disc right. I love this disc for the fact that I can run these long putts straight at the basket. the stability of this disc is right in that sweet spot.
Inside the circle, this disc is equally great. I find that it's done nothing but improve my accuracy on those 40ft an in putts. The Warden is a really straight putter. If I miss, I know I didn't hit my release point where I should have. I think that makes this disc great for a beginner to improve putting form and for seasoned players who are looking for a really accurate putter and don't quite putt hard enough for a 1 to 2 stability disc.
The only time this disc can be a bit tricky is in the wind, especially headwind. I find that if I add extra spin and hyzer to my putts, this can be counteracted pretty easily with practice and I would rather not switch to a more stable disc due to the conditions, but that's just me =)
As for throwing, I am just starting to adopt the Warden as a throwing putter in order to simplify my bag and increase consistency and feel in my discs. This disc will take any line you want to put it on from hyzer, to straight, to anhyzer and help to develop good form. I used to throw the Judge, and to be honest, I don't find much difference in the two aside from (you guessed it) the bead. The Judge may be a tiny bit more overstable and the Warden may have a bit more glide, but it's mostly negligible, especially if you're like me and not throwing a putter for anything over 250ft.
When throwing/putting with slower speed discs, I always drape my index finger over the rim as opposed to how some players point their index finger forward on the rim without it actually being slightly under this disc. For me, the bead sometimes catches on my finger and creates inconsistencies. The Warden gets me a cleaner release and my putts. At the end of the day, that's why I choose the Warden over the Judge, or any other putter for that matter.
Hope this helps someone with their next purchase. Happy discing!